Distinguishing a true from a false miracle is important to the defense
of the Christian faith. For miracles are the unique way God confirms a
truth claim to be from him. But the counterfeit cannot be detected
unless one knows the characteristics of a genuine.
A true miracle has preconditions. A miracle is a
special act of God, and there cannot be acts of God unless there is a
God who can perform these special acts. Miracles can occur only within
the context of a theistic worldview. A miracle is a divine
intervention in the world. God cannot "intervene" unless he is in some
real sense transcendent over it. Transcendence must also mean that God
has super-natural power. A God who created the world out of
nothing, ex nihilo, has the power to intervene.
Atheists look at the same event as a theist, for
example the resurrection of Christ, and from the viewpoint of their
worldview see no miracle. Whatever happened must be an anomaly,
unusual, perhaps, but someday explainable through natural processes.
If confronted with a resurrection, pantheists do not admit a divine
intervention has occurred, for they do not believe in a God who
created all things. Pantheists hold that God is all things. Hence, a
resurrection could only be an unusual even within the world, not a
supernatural event from outside it.
Description of a True Miracle.
The three words Scripture uses to describe a miracle help delineate
that meaning more precisely. Each of the three words for supernatural
events (sign, wonder, power) delineates an aspect of a miracle. From
the human vantage point, a miracle is an unusual event ("wonder") that
conveys and confirms an unusual message ("sign") by means of an
unusual power ("Power"). From the divine vantage point a miracle is an
act of God ("power") that attracts the attention of the people of God
("wonder") to the Word of God (by a "sign").
According to the Bible, a miracle has five
dimensions that together differentiate a true miracle from a false
miracle. First, a true miracle has an unnatural dimension. A
burning bush that is not consumed, fire from heaven, and walking on
water are not normal occurrences. Their unusual character commands
attention. Second, a true miracle has a theological dimension.
It presupposes the theistic God who can perform these special acts.
Third, a true miracle has a moral dimension. It manifests the
moral character of God. There are no evil miracles, because God is
good. A miracle that punishes or judges establishes God’s nature as
just.
Forth, a miracle has a teleological dimension.
Unlike magic, miracles never entertain (see Luke 23:8). Their overall
purpose is to glorify the Creator. Though unnatural, they fit into
creation and befit the nature of the Creator. The virgin birth, for
example, was supernatural in its operation, unnatural in its
properties, but purposeful in its product. It was unnatural, yet not
anti-natural. Mary’s virgin conception resulted in a normal nine-month
pregnancy and birth.1
Fifth, miracles in the Bible, particularly the gifts of miracles, had
a doctrinal dimension. They directly or indirectly verified
truth claims. They show that a prophet is truly sent from God (Deut.
18:22). They confirm the truth of God through the servant of God (Acts
2:22; 2 Cor. 12:12; Heb. 2:3-4). Message and miracles go hand-in-hand.
Distinguishing Marks of a Miracle.
In addition to its dimensions, a true miracle has distinguishing
marks. The most basic is that a true miracle is an exception to
natural law. Natural laws are regular, predictable events, but
miracles are special, unpredictable events. Of course, there are some
unusual natural events or anomalies that are sometimes confused with
miracle. Meteors, eclipses, and other natural phenomena were once
though to be miracles, but are not. Meteors pass our way infrequently,
but they are purely natural and predictable. Eclipses are natural and
predictable. Earthquakes are relatively unpredictable, but as
scientists understand them better they know where they will occur, if
not precisely when. That they are not miracles does not mean they do
not belong to God’s special providence. He uses them and is in control
of them. We can be sure that sometimes he intervenes in their
operation in dramatic ways. A fog at Normandy aided the Allied Forces’
invasion of Europe on D-Day and the eventual defeat of Nazi Germany.
Fog has natural causes, but the timing of this one was an evidence of
God’s providence. But it was no miracle. Bullets bouncing off the
chests of Allied soldiers would have been a miracle.
A true miracle also produces immediate results.
In Matthew 8:3, Jesus touched a man and immediately he was cured of
his leprosy. All of the miraculous healings by Jesus and the apostles
had such immediacy. No miracle took months, or hours. Only one
required a few minutes, because it was a two-stage miracle—actually
two interconnected instantaneous acts of God (Mark 8:23-25). By
contrast, natural events take time and process. It takes a whole
season to grow, harvest, grind and mix wheat flour for bread, but
Jesus made it instantly (John 6). It takes eighteen years or longer to
grow an adult human being, but God created Adam immediately (Gen.
1:27; 2:7).
A characteristic of a true miracle is that it
always brings glory to God. Occult "magic" brings glory to the
magician, and psychosomatic "cures" to the one who performs them.
Satanic delusions (see 2 Thess. 2:9; Rev. 16:14) are lies (2 Thess
2:9) that do not glorify the God who cannot lie (Titus 1:2; Heb.
6:18).
While miracles are not natural events, they bring
good to the natural world. The resurrection is the ultimate
example. It reverses death and brings back the good of life (see
Romans 8). Healing restores the body to the way God made it, which was
"good" (Gen. 1:27-31). Even "negative" miracles are good in that it is
good for God’s justice to defeat sin.
True miracles never fail.
They are acts of the God for whom "all things are possible" (Matt.
19:26). Since God cannot fail, neither can miracles. This does not
mean that any servant of God can perform a miracle at any time.
Miracles occur only according to God’s will (Heb 2:3-4; 1 Cor. 12:11).
Further, true miracles have no relapses. If a person is miraculously
healed, that healing is permanent. Pseudo-miracles, particularly the
psychosomatic kind, often fail. They do not work on people who do not
believe, and sometimes they do not work on those who do believe. When
they do work, their effect is often only partial and/or temporary.
(to be continued)
(from Baker Encyclopedia of Christian Apologetics (Grand
Rapids, MI: Baker Book House, 1999)