In its December 27, 1993 issue, Time magazine commented, "If
there is such a thing as a universal idea, common across cultures and
through the centuries, the belief in angels comes close to it" (p.
58). Polls indicate that almost three out of four adult Americans,
including teenagers, believe in angels. At one point, five of the ten
books on Publishers Weekly best-seller list dealt with the
subject of angels and six prime time TV specials have captivated
millions.
But what is most noteworthy about the modern, popular angels
is their dissimilarity when compared with the biblical angels. The
popular angels of today deny Christ’s teachings, are related to the
modern channeling movement and the world of the occult, seek to
possess people, are very concerned about the environment in a
pantheistic/nature worship sense, engage in distorting the Scriptures
in their revelations, appear in near-death experiences, and perhaps
not surprisingly, are very concerned with self-esteem/self-love
teachings, the practice of divination and the "faith"/positive
confession movement.
For example, consider one popular angel book in which the author
tells us, "The angels are extremely practical in showing us our false
beliefs."1 Yet, the angel’s
teachings proceed to distort what Scripture teaches. Concerning the
greatest commandment (Matt. 22:37), the angel tells us, "Start with
the first and greatest commandment, which is to love the Lord Self
with every particle of feeling you have…."2
Or consider the following personal meditation provided by the angels,
"All that God is, I AM…I AM divine purity…I AM perfect love…I AM the
peace that goes beyond understanding…I AM omnipotent…I AM perfect
judgment… the I AM THAT I AM…for I AM the joy of the world."3
In our article next month, we will examine and document why we
believe that millions of Americans are currently being deceived by
this modern fascination with angels.
What Are the Dangers to the Church?
Recent polls indicate that almost three out of four adult
Americans, including teenagers, believe in angels. That’s a whopping
two hundred million people! In late 1993 Time magazine noted
that five of the ten books on the religious best-seller list for
Publishers Weekly were about angels, and currently there are some
200 books either in print or being rushed to print on the subject. At
least half a dozen one to two hour national prime-time specials on
angels have also captivated millions of people.
In one sense, this is really nothing new; the spiritism that has
been making its way into the American mainstream for the past 25 years
has simply been repackaged in a more benevolent light. Put another
way, the recent angel craze is simply occultism with a divine twist
marketed under new management, so to speak.
How do we know that the popular angels are not who they claim to
be? Because their activities and teachings reveal their true identity.
Not only do these angels function in the manner similar or identical
to occult spirit guides, they are contacted through traditional occult
methods.
Thus, the teachings of the angels given in popular angel literature
are no different than the teachings found in modern channeled
literature. For example, "You and God are one" and "all
religions…worship the same God."4
Again, this is nothing new. It is the fallen angels which
the Bible identifies as demons or evil spirits that have been behind
the majority of false religious beliefs of humankind. For
example, "angels" were predominant in either the origin or sustenance
of most major world religions, such as Islam (the "Angel Gabriel" who
gave the revelations in the Qur’an), Hinduism and Buddhism. "Angels"
are influential in cults as well. In Mormonism it was the "Angel
Moroni" who led Joseph Smith to the alleged gold plates from which the
Book of Mormon was occultly translated. In the Jehovah’s
Witnesses and their biased New World Translation of the Bible,
"angels" have also played a key role as we documented in The Facts
on Jehovah’s Witnesses. Other cults and religions sporting angelic
influence include Emmanuel Swedenborg’s The Church of the New
Jerusalem, Rudolph Steiner’s Anthroposophy, Silva Mind Control, the
Self-Realization Fellowship, and the Unity School of Christianity.
These are only a few of the religions and cults in which angels have
played either a dominant or important role.5
What is perhaps most disconcerting is the manner in which the
"popular" angels have influenced some Christians. Books such as the
Reverend Edward W. Oldring’s I Work With Angels and I Walk
and Talk With Angels; minister G. D. Gilmore’s Angels,
Angels, Everywhere, and Rev. Roland Buck’s Angels on Assignment
are only three of many whose teachings prove that the angels spoken of
are not the godly angels. Despite their semblance of Christianity,
these books either deny biblical teachings or actually teach occultism
in various forms.6 Indeed, most
popular angel books support the world of the occult.
In Angel Wisdom we find the encouragement to use mantras and
mandalas; shamanistic vision quests and contacting one’s power animal
(a spirit guide who appears in the form of an animal); manipulation of
chakras, psychic healing, etc.7 In
Angelic Messenger Cards, we find divination and people guided
to accept contacting the dead.8 In
Creating With the Angels we find dreamwork: "Dream time is
spirit time and offers a great opportunity to play with the angels….
Allow the angels to help you interpret your dreams."9 In The Angels Within Us, we find angels taking people deep into
altered states of consciousness in order to establish contact with
them.10 The angels also support New
Age Medicine and occult holistic health practices.11
But what is even more troubling is the connection existing between
the popular angels and the Christian "faith" or "positive confession"
movements.
Angels and "Positive Confession"
In spite of their spiritistic nature, many of the modern angel
books use terminology directed toward Christians. One particularly
potent occult text encourages the reader to "endow each angel with the
Will of God, the Love of Christ, and the Action of the Holy Spirit."12
Although discerning Christians can easily see through such ruses,
there is one area in particular that uninstructed Christians may be
vulnerable. Both the modern "Faith" and "New Age" movements share
particular teachings concerning angels. Therefore, Christians who are
instructed in the former area may also be vulnerable to the more
pervasive deceptions in the latter.
As we documented in The Facts on the Faith Movement and
The Facts on False Teachings in the Church, the modern
faith/positive confession teachers almost universally claim that they
have received their unique teachings by direct divine revelation,
including through the mediation of angels. In those book, we have
proven that these teachings are not biblical and hence could not have
come from God or the good angels.13
So where did they come from?
Perhaps it is significant that many spirit guides today have entire
series of positive confession tapes which are sold by their mediums.
(The tapes by "DaBen" and "Orin" include such titles as, "Creating
Money: The Spiritual Law of Prosperity and Abundance" and "Awakening
Your Prosperity Self."14)
But the popular angels also actively support and endorse positive
confession teachings. As Terry Lynn Taylor remarks, "Angels are the
missing link in the chain of…self-help, self-development, and
self-reliance programs…. Angels are heaven-sent agents who are always
available to help you create heaven in your life."15
The entire purpose of the book, Creating With the Angels: An
Angel-Guided Journey into Creativity, is to use angels to create
success in every area of life.16 As
one angel says, "Abundance is a state of mind that leads to physical
manifestation of physical resources. But, more important, abundance is
a state of spirit that initially awakens the mind to its creative
possibilities. You are being led toward abundant thinking, feeling,
loving, and participating in life so that you will be in a position to
encourage wholism in every form, wherever you find it."17
In fact, the angels speak in exactly the same terms and cite
exactly the same scriptures as the modern Christian prosperity
teachers. For example, in the occult text, The Angels Within Us,
we read, "The Bible also says, ‘By your words you will be
justified, and by your words you will be condemned’ (Matt. 12:37);
‘Death and life are in the power of the tongue’ (Prov. 18:21); And
‘Thou shall also decree a thing, and it shall be established unto
thee’ (Job 22:28). Charles Fillmore, cofounder of Unity, wrote, ‘the
spoken word carries vibrations through the universal ether…. And
Ernest Holmes, founder of the Church of Religious Science, has
written, ‘The word gives form to the unformed….’"18
Now consider other teachings from this same occult book that
reflect basic "Christian" prosperity beliefs: "…we should meditate for
an understanding of what produced the original condition of lack in
our minds, speak the word for a healing of that mental-emotional
condition, and then work consciously with the Angel of Abundance to
reveal a divinely prosperous life."19
Or, "Abundance is the true nature of God… And when you identify this
Spirit of God within as your abundance, your consciousness becomes the
principle of prosperity. The energy flows into manifestation through
you, forever reproducing the vibration of your consciousness in the
world of form."20 Or, "When you
contemplate the God Self I Am as infinite supply...you are deepening
your awareness of the truth of your Reality."21
Consider the following advice by the angel: "I have promised you
unlimited prosperity…. I am the Lord your healer, I heal all your
diseases, restore health to you, and heal your wounds. This is not to
come. It is. In truth, you are healed now; you are whole."22
Thus, the author tells his readers, "Make contact with the angel and
ask how you are limiting your own success. Let him show you any false
beliefs that may be blocking the flow from his perspective."23
Now consider similar teachings from other contemporary books on
angels: "True abundance is the ability to see the abundance that is
already ours."24 "I harness the
power that enables me to realize all of my desires and objectives…. I
have the power to know what is best."25
"If we believe that we can have something…our higher selves—the parts
of our psyches that are in communication with the angels—will begin to
create it for us."26 "I create my
own miracles."27
All this is proof positive that the modern Christian prosperity
movement has aligned itself with the very same teachings given
by the spirit world. Now, if we know that these kinds of
teachings derive not from the good angels but from the fallen angels
or demons, and if we know that the faith teachers claim to receive
unbiblical teachings by supernatural inspiration, the conclusion would
seem self-evident.
What all this means is that the "Faith" teachers who instruct
millions of Christians may unwittingly be influencing them to also
accept the teachings of demons masquerading as angels.
Consider the following and listen to the words of the "Faith"
teachers themselves before you make a decision.
Kenneth Copeland teaches, "…when you use the Word in the name of
Jesus [that is, in positive confession] they [angels] are obligated to
follow your command."28
Gloria
Copeland suggests there may be at least 40,000 angels assigned to each
believer, thus, "there is no shortage of angel power;"29
and, "how long do you think it would take them to make you wealthy?"30
Unfortunately, "for the most part, the heirs of the promise have not
been using the angel power available to them."31
Thus, "Your words put the angels to work on your behalf to bring to
pass whatever you say…the words of your mouth bind them or loose them
to work for you."32
Charles Capps says God supernaturally revealed the same truths to
him. In Angels he says, "You need the supernatural beings of
God working for you here on earth."33
In Releasing the Ability of God, he states, "The Spirit of God
spoke this into my spirit just as plainly as if I heard it with my
ears…. He said: ‘The Word says the angels are ministering spirits.
These ministering spirits stand beside you daily and listen to the
words that you speak…. but you are the one who tells them what to do."34
Thus, "Angels will work for you. They will become involved in every
area of your life—your home, your business, everything—but only to the
extent that you allow them to operate."35
Prosperity teacher Kenneth Hagin claims that in 1958 "the Lord
Jesus suddenly appeared" before him, with an angel standing three feet
behind Him. In I Believe in Visions, he reveals, "He [Jesus]
said, ‘This is your angel.’ ‘My angel?’ I asked. ‘Yes, your angel, and
if you will respond to him, he will appear to you as I will at times;
and he will give you guidance and direction concerning the things of
life,…"36
Jerry Savelle says that when we apply the principles of the Faith
Movement, "…the angels come on the scene to see that what you say
comes to pass."37
John Osteen teaches, "When you become a covenant-person, God
assigns angels to watch you and your family…."38
Robert Tilton says, "When you talk positively about your dream, you
not only release its substance, but you release the angels to work for
you, causing your dream to come to pass."39
Benny Hinn also accepts the supposed ministry of the "faith"
angels.40
But by teaching Christians that angels are indeed anxiously
standing by to do one’s personal bidding, prosperity leaders are
conditioning Christians to have a particular expectation about angels
that is not biblical. To teach that angels will give personal
"guidance and direction," that they "will become involved in every
area of your life" and generate "financial prosperity" is exactly what
channelers with spirit guides claim for the spirits they contact. In
essence, Christians who think that the primary purpose of the angels
is to service them with prosperity may be more open to establishing
contact with the prosperity "angels" of the New Age movement.
Consider that in 1987 charismatic and "prosperity" evangelist
Kenneth Copeland gave a prophecy "from Jesus Christ" in which "Jesus"
promised that new and dramatic angel manifestations were going to
increase in the church and that many "will have visitations from the
spirit realm." Concerning angels, "Jesus" allegedly told Copeland:
A very outstanding time is on the way. A time is coming when
there will be a manifestation of angels more than usual, more than
what there has been in the past. Many of you are going to witness
for yourselves the angel that has been put in charge and in command
of your ministry and your life. Many of you are going to have
visitations from the spirit realm. Many of you will have divinely
appointed visions and dreams. …Oh, there’s no time nor distance in
the spirit realm. You’ll be connected together at times like you’ve
never witnessed before. Suddenly, you’ll be standing in that
[spiritual] country, and suddenly you’ll deliver a message and then
suddenly you’ll be brought back in your kitchen again. Oh, I have
some outstanding things, sayeth the Lord.41
1 John Randolph, The Angels
Within Us: A Spiritual Guide to the Twenty-Two Angels that Govern
Our Lives (New York, NY: Fawcett-Columbine, 1993), p.62.
2 Ibid., p. 63.
3 Ibid., p. 276.
4 Meredith L. Young-Sowers,
Angelic Messenger Cards: A Divination System for Spiritual Discovery
(Walpole, NH: Stillpoint, 1993) 58; Terry Lynn Taylor and Mary Beth
Crain, Angel Wisdom: 365 Meditations and Insights from the
Heavens (NY: Harper Collins, 1994), April 13.
5 See John Ankerberg, John
Weldon, The Facts on Angels (Eugene, OR: Harvest House,
1995).
6 Ibid.
7 Taylor and Crain, June 18th,
28th; July 8th, 22nd; October 20th.
8 Meredith L. Young-Sowers, p.
31.
9 Terry Lynn Taylor,
Creating with the Angels: An Angel-Guided Journey Into Creativity
(Tiburon, CA: H. J. Kramer, 1993), pp. 39, 41.
10 Price, The Angels Within
Us, p. 16.
11 "Angels II: Beyond the
Light," NBC, October 30, 1994, 7 P.M., Host: Stefanie Powers.
12 Price, The Angels Within
Us, p. 31.
13 Available from the
Ankerberg Theological Research Institute or your Christian
bookstore.
14 Sanaya Roman and Duane
Packer, Opening to Channel: How to Connect with Your Guide
(Tiburon, CA: H. J. Kramer, Inc. 1987), pp. 231-232.
15 Terry Lynn Taylor,
Messengers of Light: The Angel’s Guide to Spiritual Growth
(Tiburon, CA: H. J. Kramer, 1990), xvi.
16 Taylor, Creating With
the Angels, vii-xi.
17 Young-Sowers, Angelic
Messenger Cards, p. 214.
18 Price, 268.
19 Ibid., p. 58.
20 Ibid., pp. 56-57.
21 Ibid., pp. 88, 96.
22 Ibid., pp. 263-264.
23 Ibid., p. 286.
24 Taylor and Crain, Angel
Wisdom, February 8.
25 Ibid., January 11, 21.
26 Ibid., May 22.
27 Ibid., September 14.
28 Kenneth Copeland, The
Laws of Prosperity (Fort Worth, TX: Kenneth Copeland
Publications, 1974), p. 104.
29 Gloria Copeland, God’s
Will is Prosperity (Fort Worth, TX: Kenneth Copeland
Publications, 1978), pp. 84-85.
30 Ibid., p. 86.
31 Ibid., p. 65.
32 Ibid., p. 88.
33 Charles Capps, Angels
(England, AZ: Charles Capps Publishers, 1984), p. 80.
34 Charles Capps, Releasing
the Ability of God (England, AZ: Charles Capps Publishers,
1978), pp. 100-101, 105.
35 Capps, Angels, p.
173.
36 Kenneth Hagin, I Believe
in Visions (Tulsa, OK: Kenneth Hagin Ministries), p. 93.
37 Jerry Savelle,
Energizing Your Faith (Fort Worth, TX: Jerry Savelle Ministries,
1983), p. 45.
38 John Osteen, Unraveling
the Mystery of the Blood Covenant (Houston, TX: John Osteen
Ministries, 1987), p. 45.
39 Robert Tilton, Climb
Your Ladder of Success (Dallas, TX: Robert Tilton Ministries,
1988), p. 54.
40 In The Christian
Sentinel, Vol. 1, No. 1., p. 13. The word "spirit" was
capitalized in this quotation. However, since this was a claimed
supernatural prophecy to Copeland, the use of capitals was an
editorial assumption.
41 Kenneth Copeland, "Take
Time to Pray," Believer’s Voice of Victory, Vol. 15, No. 2,
February 1987, p. 9.